Time to take a look back at how my first season went making last minute pickups. As I stated on the page, these are players owned in less than 20% (and preferably less than 10%) of leagues that I excepted to have a good fantasy week. In other words, last minute plug-and-play desperation picks. I did better than I expected in my initial season doing this but certainly hoping for even better next year. Here’s a quick review of things.
Overall Grades
I made 5 picks every week for a total of 85 all season. 5 players got injured or, in 1 case, ended up not playing. Here’s how the other 80 turned out on my grading.
Number of ‘A’ grades: 23
‘B’ grades: 8
‘C’ grades: 7
‘D’ grades: 9
‘F’ grades: 33
Calculated “GPA”: 1.74
Ugh. Feels a little worse doing the GPA calculation but still not as bad as I expected considering what I’m picking from. Prior to the season, I honestly thought I’d really hit on maybe 10-12 picks. Came away with essentially double that. I’m happy, mostly.
Best Pickups of the Year
Was going to just pick one but there’s 5 that kind of stick out fairly equally. That said, here they are.
Week 5 – Austin Davis – Projected 26th among QB – Finished 3rd
I expected the big week against the Eagles poor pass D and Davis came through. Definitely one of the biggest highlights of his season before losing the job again. I wouldn’t expect him to see the field too many more times in his career as he just didn’t show enough when given the opportunity.
Week 6 – Andre Holmes – Projected 108th among WR – Finished 2nd
A big play guy that made some big plays this week. The Raiders have some nice pieces on offense like Holmes, Jones, and Rivera. Now if they could just find someone to coach them appropriately…
Week 6 – Jace Amaro – Projected 37th among TE – Finished 4th
Finished this week #1 among TEs in PPR so kind of nailed this one. Injury derailed his season a bit along with the erratic QB play. I would expect him to be a huge sleeper depending on how the coaching and QB situation plays out in New York. He has top 10 and possibly top 5 talent at the position, in my opinion.
Week 9 – Chase Ford – Projected 88th among TE – Finished 6th
Really think he kind of went under the radar a bit in terms of how good he could be. Liked what I saw and think he could be an impact player down the road assuming he gets the chance to develop a bit. Will be tough behing Rudolph but maybe a trade or cut happens in the off-season that opens a door for him.
Week 12 – Charles Johnson – Projected 223rd among WR (technically true!) – Finished 12th
I was initially really excited about Johnson but that excitement dwindled as the season finished out. I think he might end up a bit overrated next season and I might be pretty leery about him come draft day. Just don’t think he can consistently produce as a #1 WR, assuming that is where he begins the season next year.
Worst Pickup of the Year
Plenty to chose from in terms of the F grades but this one really stuck out in my mind.
Week 7 – Dexter McCluster – Projected 70th among RB – Finished 90th
Finished the week with a negative score and was dead last among all RBs that logged time that week. I assumed the Titans were, at some point, going to start giving him 10-15 touches simply out of desperation at the position but this week convinced me that was never going to happen. By this week, I was honestly not sure why the Titans bothered to sign him. They clearly didn’t know how to use his ability.